LOGIN | REGISTER NOW | SUBSCRIBE
 
print Printable version 
Most Read Latest News Blog Resources
Does Windows cost Microsoft opportunities?
Microsoft's decision to focus .NET on Windows is stifling innovation due to the specter of...

Mono brings .NET to Android
At Microsoft MIX, Mono will unveil the ability to port .NET applications to the Android op...

OSBC focus turns to best practices for open-source adoption
Businesses are no longer asking why they should adopt, but how do they use open source leg...

Digg!  Digg
Reddit  Reddit
Slashdot  Slashdot
Share on facebook  Facebook
Share on Twitter  Twitter

Abuse of The Community Process


By SD Times News Team
January 15, 2006 — 
BEA, IBM and Sun are at it again. Remember that a key principle behind the Java community was “Collaborate on standards, compete on implementation”? Well, of late, developers have heard more about “compete on standards.”

The latest culprit is a spec called the Service Component Architecture, proposed by a bevy of companies, including BEA, IBM and Iona. Sun’s crying foul, complaining that SCA partially duplicates work already done by JSR 208, the Java Business Integration (JBI) specification unveiled as the centerpiece of last summer’s JavaOne.

But don’t forget: JSR 208 wasn’t a slam dunk. Both BEA and IBM abstained in the final approval ballot for Java Business Integration, and clearly those companies feel no loyalty toward a Java Community Process initiative that they didn’t support.

Worse, the fact that BEA and IBM pushed this particular project, which includes both SCA and an earlier project from the two companies called Service Data Objects, outside the Java Community Process makes one wonder exactly what the JSP is for. Complicating matters is that SCA is billed as a language-independent platform, so while it in part duplicates JBI, it’s not clear if the JCP is truly the best place for it.

According to Iona’s Eric Newcomer—who supports both JBI and SCA/SDO—the proposal will go to Eclipse, a Sun nemesis, instead of the JCP. But if that’s the plan, why were these specs developed behind closed doors, rather than using the Eclipse collaborative process?

Despite the broad acceptance of organizations like the JCP, the Eclipse Foundation and the Apache Software Foundation, it’s still far too common for companies like BEA and IBM to develop complete technologies and specifications first, and deploy them within their own products. Only after they have a comfortable head start, do they seek a community rubber stamp of the completed work. (Microsoft is just as guilty, using Ecma International to “fast track” specifications, like the Office 12 XML schema and C# language, into de facto industry standards.)

These practices abuse the notion of community development and “open standards.”

Groups like the JCP, Eclipse, Apache and Ecma should only accept projects if there is some real chance that different interest groups will have a legitimate say in the development of the specifications and technologies. Being presented with a complete spec as a fait accompli—and then endorsing that spec essentially unchanged—merely demonstrates that these organizations are focused on pleasing their corporate sponsors, not just on developing best-of-breed specifications that create opportunities and broaden a standard base for innovation.

If companies like BEA, IBM and Microsoft have good ideas for developing specifications, and want those specs to be endorsed by industry consortia, they should develop such specifications within those industry consortia, in an open, transparent and competitive manner. Then, and only then, should those consortia endorse them as standard. Rubber stamping does the software development industry a disservice. It’s time for the consortia to just say no.


Share this link: http://www.sdtimes.com/link/29083
 

Add comment


Name*
Email*  
Country     


  • Comment
  • Preview
Loading



 
 
 
 
News on Monday
more>>
SharePoint Tech Report
more>>


   

 
 
Download Current Issue
ISSUE 3/15/2010 PDF

Need Back Issues?
DOWNLOAD HERE

Receive the print Edition?


 
blogs tab
Google Code turns 5
Google Code Turns 5, and adds a Paxos Algorithm to make the system more stable and reliable.
03/17/2010 11:16 AM EST

Test your Visual Studio 2010 know-how
Microsoft is offering free beta certification exams for Visual Studio 2010.
03/17/2010 11:08 AM EST

Microsoft lifts the hood on IE9
Microsoft is previewing IE9.
03/16/2010 01:10 PM EST

 

Events calendar tab
EclipseCon
3/22/2010 to 3/25/2010
Santa Clara, Calif.
The Eclipse Foundation

DevConnections
4/12/2010 to 4/14/2010
Las Vegas
Penton Media

MySQL Conf. and Expo
4/12/2010 to 4/15/2010
Santa Clara, Calif.
O'Reilly Media

High Performance Computing Linux Financial Markets
4/19/2010
New York City
Flagg Management

Informix User Conf.
4/25/2010 to 4/28/2010
Overland Park, Kans.
IIUG