LOGIN | REGISTER NOW | SUBSCRIBE
 
print Printable version 
Most Read Latest News Blog Resources
Mono brings .NET to Android
At Microsoft MIX, Mono will unveil the ability to port .NET applications to the Android op...

Does Windows cost Microsoft opportunities?
Microsoft's decision to focus .NET on Windows is stifling innovation due to the specter of...

OSBC focus turns to best practices for open-source adoption
Businesses are no longer asking why they should adopt, but how do they use open source leg...

Digg!  Digg
Reddit  Reddit
Slashdot  Slashdot
Share on facebook  Facebook
Share on Twitter  Twitter

GPL Patent Rule Pending


License might limit infringement lawsuits

By Alex Handy
June 1, 2006 — 
A provision regarding patent protection in a draft of the upcoming revision to the GNU General Public License has concerned corporate patent holders, who are worried that the new license will limit their ability to protect their software patents.

Of particular interest is a section of GPL 3 that dictates the protocol for patent litigation retaliation.

Under the current draft (gplv3.fsf.org/draft), if a company or individual modifies a GPL program, then enforces a software patent to prevent others from modifying the program in the same way, the litigious party initiating the lawsuit will lose all rights to use the GPL code in question.

Eben Moglen, president and executive director of the Software Freedom Law Center, said that the Free Software Foundation does not find patent retaliation clauses to be effective, and has therefore included only one clause for retaliation in the GPL draft. “Now that everyone knows that software patents are crappy,” said Moglen, “the FSF has not lost any of its enthusiasm” for its fight against patents. “It’s just that the foundation believes that patent retaliation clauses in [other open-source] licenses lead people to believe they’ve done more about the problem than they [actually] have.”

Diane Peters, who is discussing the changes to the GPL with large corporations in her capacity as general counsel for the Open Source Development Labs (OSDL), said that she expects the Free Software Foundation to address during the initial comment period many of the concerns raised by these companies with sizable patent portfolios.

“If I sue someone with a patent based on GPL v3 software, I have to choose between suing or running that GPL v3 software. It’s the first time FSF has ever reached in and controlled private behavior,” said Peters. “Every other provision in GPL v2 is triggered by distribution.”

The confusion here stems from the ambiguity of where in the patented software GPL code must exist in order to invalidate a lawsuit. If the entity enforcing the patent used GCC during its development process, Peters worries that this could be enough to negate the suit.

It is possible for a company to have GPL 3 code in its software stack without knowing about it, said Peters. “Then, if they choose to sue someone for infringement, the defendant can then go on a hunt for any GPL v3 code used in the company, and if they find it, they can say, ‘Aha, you can’t sue me.’ This may be changed. My hope is they change it to trigger by distribution, not by just privately running code.”

The next iteration should be arriving sometime around the beginning of July, and is expected to remove a good deal of the ambiguity and uncertainty from the draft document.

Moglen went on to say that the GPL 3 now includes the ability to integrate code released under other licenses, and as such, outside patent retaliation clauses could find their way into codebases that merge both GPL 3 code and, for example, the Apache Software License. The trick here

is figuring out which license clauses will remain dominant after a merger, something which Moglen and Peters expect will be clarified in the next draft release.

Moglen also expects the FSF to rework the way the GPL 3 deals with patent license holders offering protections to downstream users of potentially patent-infringing GPL code.


Share this link: http://www.sdtimes.com/link/29352
 

Add comment


Name*
Email*  
Country     


  • Comment
  • Preview
Loading



 
 
 
 
News on Monday
more>>
SharePoint Tech Report
more>>


   

 
 
Download Current Issue
ISSUE 3/15/2010 PDF

Need Back Issues?
DOWNLOAD HERE

Receive the print Edition?


 
blogs tab
Google Code turns 5
Google Code Turns 5, and adds a Paxos Algorithm to make the system more stable and reliable.
03/17/2010 11:16 AM EST

Test your Visual Studio 2010 know-how
Microsoft is offering free beta certification exams for Visual Studio 2010.
03/17/2010 11:08 AM EST

Microsoft lifts the hood on IE9
Microsoft is previewing IE9.
03/16/2010 01:10 PM EST

 

Events calendar tab
EclipseCon
3/22/2010 to 3/25/2010
Santa Clara, Calif.
The Eclipse Foundation

DevConnections
4/12/2010 to 4/14/2010
Las Vegas
Penton Media

MySQL Conf. and Expo
4/12/2010 to 4/15/2010
Santa Clara, Calif.
O'Reilly Media

High Performance Computing Linux Financial Markets
4/19/2010
New York City
Flagg Management

Informix User Conf.
4/25/2010 to 4/28/2010
Overland Park, Kans.
IIUG